How the Second Amendment Works


What Is the Future of the Second Amendment?
Students hold up their hands while taking part in National School Walkout Day to protest school violence on April 20, 2018 in Chicago. The rally was held on the 19th anniversary of the Columbine school shooting. Jim Young/Getty Images

Justice Stevens' startling advocacy of repealing the Second Amendment provided ammunition to gun rights supporters such as President Trump, who in a February 2018 speech at CPAC claimed that if his Democratic opponents gained control of Congress in the 2018 midterm elections, "they'll take away your Second Amendment" [source: Cillizza].

In truth, there's been no indication that Democratic politicians are considering such a move. The party's 2016 platform did call for measures such as expanding background checks for gun purchases, but it also stated that "we can respect the rights of responsible gun owners while keeping our communities safe."

And political rhetoric aside, it seems unlikely that the Second Amendment will ever be repealed. For one thing, it's complicated and difficult to take something out of the Constitution. Such a move first would have to be approved by two-thirds of both the U.S. House and the U.S. Senate, and then by 38 of the nation's 50 state legislatures.

From 1789 through 2016, an estimated 11,699 changes to the Constitution were proposed in Congress, but only one amendment has ever been repealed — the 18th Amendment imposing Prohibition, which was enacted in 1919 and subsequently repealed in 1933 by ratification of the 21st Amendment [source: Bomboy].

And unlike the repeal of Prohibition, which was widely supported by the public, most Americans don't want to repeal the Second Amendment. A February 2018 Economist/YouGov poll, for example, found that only 21 percent of Americans favored repeal. In contrast, 60 percent of the public opposed removing the amendment [source: Economist/YouGov].

But while a strong majority of Americans want the right to bear arms to continue to be enshrined in the Constitution, the Economist/YouGov poll found that nearly half — 46 percent — favored the idea of modifying it to allow stricter regulation of guns, versus 39 percent who want it to stay unchanged [source: Economist/YouGov].

It's unclear, though, how the Second Amendment could be revised without going through the arduous process of passing another constitutional amendment. That means that, for the foreseeable future at least, the Second Amendment probably will remain as it is now, and it'll be up to the Supreme Court to decide what the right to bear arms actually means.

Author's Note: How the Second Amendment Works

The Second Amendment is the section of the Constitution that stirs up the most powerful feelings and the most impassioned debate. That makes it a challenging subject to write about.

Related Articles

More Great Links

Sources

  • Barnes, Robert and Eggen, Dan. "Supreme Court affirms fundamental right to bear arms." Washington Post. June 29, 2010. (April 13, 2018) https://wapo.st/2HAyTXJ
  • Bogus, Carl T. "The Hidden History of the Second Amendment." UC Davis Law Review. 1998. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2GZAJjR
  • Bomboy, Scott. "Mass Shootings Renew Second Amendment Weapons Debate." National Constitution Center. Dec. 14, 2012. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2HAG16u
  • Bomboy, Scott. "What does it take to repeal a constitutional amendment?" National Constitution Center. March 28, 2018. (April 16, 2018) http://bit.ly/2J1xoBv
  • Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms. "Laws on Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives." Atf.gov. (April 16, 2018) http://bit.ly/2BJHN1Y
  • Cillizza, Chris. "Donald Trump stokes a totally false idea on the 2nd Amendment in CPAC speech." CNN. Feb. 23, 2018. (April 16, 2018) https://cnn.it/2IZ5Qwo
  • Cost, Jay. "What the Second Amendment Means Today." National Review. February 19, 2018. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2Hxz71F
  • Democrats.org. "Our Platform." Democrats.org. (April 16, 2018) http://bit.ly/2H6csc5
  • Denniston, Lyle. "Constitution Check: Are there no limits on Second Amendment rights?" Constitution Daily. Jan. 9, 2014. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2HwYPn3
  • Duggan, Paul. "Having Toppled D.C. Ban, Man Registers Revolver." Washington Post. July 19, 2008. (April 16, 2018) https://wapo.st/2J0HcLY
  • Economist/YouGov. "Economist/YouGov Poll, February 25-27, 2018—1,500 U.S. Adults." Cloudfront.net. (April 16, 2018) http://bit.ly/2IVuNc0
  • Frye, Brian L. "The Peculiar Story of United States v. Miller." Uky.edu. 2008. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2HILcBz
  • Ingraham, Christopher. "One in five Americans wants the Second Amendment to be repealed, national survey finds." Washington Post. March 27, 2018. (April 13, 2018) https://wapo.st/2HyVPGF
  • Jancer, Matt. "Gun Control Is as Old as the Old West." Smithsonian. Feb. 5, 2018. (April 16, 2018) http://bit.ly/2HBKiGE
  • Law Library of Congress. "United States: Gun Ownership and the Supreme Court." (April 13, 2018) Loc.gov. http://bit.ly/2HybO8b
  • Legal Information Institute. "Second Amendment.) Law.cornell.edu. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2HyNzq9
  • Legal Information Institute. "District of Columbia v. Heller." Law.cornell.edu. (April 16, 2018) http://bit.ly/2H214xO
  • Liptak, Adam. "Justices Extend Firearm Rights in 5-to-4 Ruling." New York Times. June 28, 2010. (April 13, 2018) https://nyti.ms/2Hzsxrx
  • Lopez, German. "How the NRA resurrected the Second Amendment." Vox. March 17, 2018. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2Hx1Svq
  • Lopen, German. "Trump: "THE SECOND AMENDMENT WILL NEVER BE REPEALED!" Vox. March 28, 2018. (April 15, 2018) http://bit.ly/2HAgn1D
  • Lund, Nelson. "Not a Second Class Right: The Second Amendment Today." National Constitution Center. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2HzJXo4
  • Lund, Nelson. "The Second Amendment, Heller, and Originalist Jurisprudence." George Mason School of Law. 2009. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2HxTJXQ
  • Lund, Nelson and Winkler, Adam. "Common Interpretation." National Constitution Center. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2HzJXo4
  • National Rifle Association-Institute for Legislative Action. "Second Amendment." Nraila.org. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2HzpU9n
  • Price, Greg. "Second Amendment History: Biggest Supreme Court Cases on Gun Control." Newsweek. March 27, 2018. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2HA42e2
  • Pruden, William H. III. "State v. Buzzard." The Encyclopedia of Arkansas History & Culture." (April 16, 2018) http://bit.ly/2HEUmyW
  • Shusterman, Noah. "What the Second Amendment really meant to the Founders." Washington Post. Feb. 22, 2018. (April 13, 2018) https://wapo.st/2GWFxX8
  • Stevens, John Paul. "John Paul Stevens: Repeal the Second Amendment." New York Times. March 27, 2018. (April 13, 2018) https://nyti.ms/2HB6mS4
  • Vandercoy, David E. "The History of the Second Amendment." Valparaiso University Law Review. Spring 1994. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2HyVJih
  • Volokh, Eugene. "Supreme Court refuses to hear right-to-carry-guns case, Justices Thomas and Gorsuch say there is such a right." Washington Post. June 26, 2017. (April 16, 2018) https://wapo.st/2J0E1UA
  • Waldman, Daniel. "Don't Repeal the Second Amendment — Just Pass Sensible Gun Law." Brennan Center for Justice. Oct. 18, 2017. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2GYNqeF
  • Waldman, Michael. "How the NRA Rewrote the Second Amendment." Politico. May 19, 2014. (April 13, 2018) https://politi.co/2HAbohk
  • Waldman, Michael. "The Second Amendment: A Biography." Simon and Schuster. 2014 (April 15, 2018) http://bit.ly/2H3F9X5
  • Winkler, Adam. "The Reasonable Right to Bear Arms." National Constitution Center. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2HzJXo4
  • Yassky, David S. "The Second Amendment: Structure, History, and
  • Constitutional Change." Michigan Law Review. 2000. (April 13, 2018) http://bit.ly/2GVBiLp
  • Zimmerman, Dan. "The Second Amendment, the Founders and Original Intent." Thetruthaboutguns.com. Sept. 5, 2014.

More to Explore