Controversies Surrounding Motivational Speakers
Perhaps unsurprisingly to skeptics, Robbins and his famed firewalk have not escaped controversy. In 2016, five people were taken to the hospital and 30 to 40 more were evaluated after sustaining burn injuries at an event in Dallas [source: Izadi]. At the time, Robbins' spokesperson, Jennifer Connelly, told the Washington Post," only five of 7,000 participants requested any examination beyond what was readily available on site. We are pleased to have completed another successful fire walk for 7,000 guests and look forward to the remainder of an outstanding weekend with them."
Wayne Dyer also faced controversy during his 40-plus years in the spotlight. In 2006, PBS viewers began complaining that he was promoting a "specific religious worldview" on the public network that many felt violated editorial policies. In 2012, PBS spokesperson Michael Getler addressed the controversy by saying it was his sense that Dyer did in fact violate the policies, but the network's board disagreed.
In 2005, investigative journalist Steve Salerno coined the term "SHAM": Self-Help and Actualization Movement. His book, "Sham: How the Self-Help Movement Made America Helpless," argued that the audience members and devotees of speakers and "gurus" invest money in products and enjoy a temporary feeling of inspiration, which eventually fades, prompting them to invest more money [source: Shermer]. Salerno explains that because there are no scientific studies to document the success of these SHAM techniques, there's no evidence that they're actually effective or whether consumers are just experiencing coincidental improvement (or no improvement at all).
Shawn Callahan, a leading business adviser says motivational speakers simply can't make people change. "Hearing one of these speakers does not build self-efficacy and belief that you can achieve something more – it may in fact do the opposite," he writes. "If people do feel inspired after hearing these people, this inspiration to change doesn't seem to withstand the twin 'attacks' on voicemails and a full inbox back at work."
Weisman, however, believes the proof is in each individual's personal experience. "The best way to tell if a speaker is a scam artist is to measure the results," she says. "Do you feel more positive, more fulfilled? Have you set goals and reached those goals? Is the community supporting, loving, giving, kind? Or, does a speaker prey on your insecurities and ask you to contribute money without results? If someone has to break you down to build you up in their image, then it's probably not the best motivational speaker. But it's important to pay attention to your intuition and your emotions. How does this person make you feel? If the answer is positive with good results, then you're on the right track."
Author's Note: How Motivational Speakers Work
While there's no single method for motivating everyone and individuals are clearly motivated by varying methods and goals, it's hard to deny that plenty of people have found strength, solace and inspiration in the words of others. While I personally believe it's important to bring a critical ear to any speaker's words (particularly when they come at a high cost), if another person's story resonates with you and brings positivity into your life, it's hard to argue against the benefits of that connection.
- "50 Greatest 'Saturday Night Live' Sketches of All Time." Rolling Stone. Feb. 3, 2014. (May 22, 2017) http://www.rollingstone.com/tv/pictures/50-greatest-saturday-night-live-sketches-of-all-time-20140203/matt-foley-motivational-speaker-0010123
- Buchanan, Leigh. "The Art and Business of Motivational Speaking." Inc. Magazine. Dec. 1, 2010. (May 25, 2017) https://www.inc.com/magazine/20101201/the-art-and-business-of-motivational-speaking.html
- Callahan, Shawn. "The problem with 'motivational speakers'." Anecdote. June 20, 2011. (June 22, 2017) http://www.anecdote.com/2011/06/the-problem-with-motivational-speakers/
- Caprino, Kathy. "Tony Robbins Reveals The Top 6 Leadership Blind Spots That Cripple Business Success." Forbes Magazine. Dec. 20, 2013. (May 22, 2017) https://www.forbes.com/sites/kathycaprino/2013/12/20/tony-robbins-reveals-the-top-6-leadership-blind-spots-that-cripple-business-success/#5fb4823c3d9c
- EdPsych Interactive. "Motivation to Learn: An Overview." (May 23, 2017) http://www.edpsycinteractive.org/topics/motivation/motivate.html
- Eha, Brian Patrick. "Zig Ziglar: A Life Lived at the Top." Entrepreneur. Nov. 29, 2012. (May 25, 2017) https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/225115
- Izadi, Elahe. "Tony Robbins asked them to overcome fear and storm across hot coals. Dozens were injured." The Washington Post. Jun. 24, 2016. (May 25, 2017) https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2016/06/24/dozens-burned-walking-on-hot-coals-at-motivational-tony-robbins-seminar/?utm_term=.609f29ee4e36
- JackCanfield.com. ""About Jack Canfield."" (May 25, 2017) http://jackcanfield.com/about-jack-canfield/
- Johnson, Alex. ""Self-Help Pioneer Dr. Wayne Dyer Dies at 75, Family and Publisher Say."" NBC News. Aug. 30, 2015. (May 26, 2017) http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/self-help-pioneer-dr-wayne-dyer-dies-75-n418556
- McLeod, Saul. "Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs." Simply Psychology. 2007, updated 2016. https://www.simplypsychology.org/maslow.html
- Morgan, Nick. "There's No Such Thing as a Motivational Speaker." Forbes Magazine. Apr. 25, 2012. (May 25, 2017) https://www.forbes.com/sites/nickmorgan/2012/04/25/theres-no-such-thing-as-a-motivational-speaker/#62ed8884502d
- National Speakers Association. "Find a Speaker." (May 25, 2017) http://www.nsaspeaker.org/find-speaker/
- Olson, Amy. "The Theory of Self-Actualization." Psychology Today. Aug. 13, 2013. (May 31, 2017) https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/theory-and-psychopathology/201308/the-theory-self-actualization
- Robinson, Peter. "Get Motivated! seminars a smoke screen for sales pitch." The Seattle Times. May 19, 2012. (June 22, 2017) http://www.seattletimes.com/business/get-motivated-seminars-a-smoke-screen-for-sales-pitch/
- Rose, Lacey, Guthrie, Marisa. "Billy Bush Breaks His Silence on Trump, the 'Access Hollywood' Tape, NBC and a Comeback Plan (Exclusive)." The Hollywood Reporter. May 21, 2017. (May 28, 2017) http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/features/billy-bush-breaks-his-silence-trump-access-hollywood-tape-nbc-a-comeback-plan-1005744
- StateUniversity.com. "Motivational Speaker Job Description, Career as a Motivational Speaker, Salary, Employment - Definition and Nature of the Work, Education and Training Requirements, Getting the Job." (May 25, 2017) http://careers.stateuniversity.com/pages/7878/Motivational-Speaker.html
- Shermer, Michael. "The Sham Scam." Scientific American. May 1, 2006. (May 25, 2017) https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/sham-scam/
- TonyRobbins.com. "Date With Destiny." (May 25, 2017) https://www.tonyrobbins.com/events/date-with-destiny/florida-12-05-2017/
- Tony Robbins Unleash The Power Within Event. "What Celebrities Talk About Tony Robbins." Jan. 10, 2014. (May 25, 2017) http://tonyrobbinsunleashthepowerwithin.com/what-celebrities-talk-about-tony-robbins/
- TonyRobbinsFirewalk.com. "What is the Tony Robbins Firewalk?" (May 25, 2017) http://www.tonyrobbinsfirewalk.com/what-is-the-tony-robbins-firewalk/